Alberta Garcia Killed in Banning Pedestrian Accident
Alberta Garcia Was Struck and Killed Crossing Highland Springs Avenue, the Same Busy Corridor Where Another Banning Woman Died in 2023
BANNING, CALIFORNIA (November 22, 2026) – A 48-year-old woman identified as Alberta Garcia was killed in a pedestrian accident on Highland Springs Avenue in Banning.
Riverside County officials are saying that the crash was reported around 12:13 p.m. on Monday. Alberta Garcia was crossing Highland Springs Avenue about 285 feet north of Joshua Palmer Way when she was struck by a vehicle traveling north, according to Patch.
The Banning Police Department’s preliminary investigation indicates that she was crossing outside a designated crosswalk and away from an intersection at the time. Emergency crews were called to the scene.
Alberta Garcia died moments after being struck. The driver stayed at the scene and cooperated with investigators, and police said they do not believe alcohol or drugs were a factor.
The Riverside County Sheriff-Coroner’s Bureau later identified her as a Banning resident.
Highland Springs Avenue has seen deadly pedestrian crashes before. In May 2023, an 84-year-old Banning woman was struck and killed by a truck while walking near Highland Springs Avenue and Sixth Street, on the Beaumont side of the corridor, according to the Beaumont Police Department.
Questions remain about how far people must walk to reach a marked or signalized crossing near Joshua Palmer Way. Whether lighting, signal spacing, or median refuges along this stretch give pedestrians a reasonable chance to cross safely deserves a close look.
Liability for Banning Pedestrian Accidents
California law divides responsibility between drivers and pedestrians, but it never removes a driver’s duty of care. Under Vehicle Code section 21950, drivers must yield to pedestrians in marked crosswalks and in unmarked crosswalks at intersections. Vehicle Code section 21954 says pedestrians outside a crosswalk must yield to vehicles close enough to be an immediate hazard, but it also states that this rule does not relieve drivers of the duty to use due care for anyone on the roadway. Since 2023, Vehicle Code section 21955 has limited citations for crossing outside a crosswalk to situations where a reasonably careful person would recognize an immediate danger of a collision. In practice, responsibility in these cases often turns on questions like these:
- Lookout:Â Drivers must watch the road ahead, including for people crossing midblock where no crosswalk exists.
- Speed:Â A safe speed for conditions gives a driver time to stop or steer around someone in the roadway.
- Visibility:Â Sun glare, parked vehicles, and roadway curves can affect what each person could see before impact.
- Crossing Access:Â Long gaps between signalized crossings can push people to cross where no crosswalk is marked.
- Road Conditions: Under Government Code section 835, a public entity may be liable when a dangerous condition of its property creates a substantial risk of injury.
California courts have long held that a pedestrian’s duty to yield does not excuse a driver’s carelessness. In Genola v. Barnett (1939), the Supreme Court of California considered the case of a woman in her early 60s who was struck while crossing Pacific Avenue in San Francisco between intersections, where the car was reportedly traveling 30 to 40 miles per hour in a 25 mph zone. The trial court had ruled for the driver, finding the pedestrian negligent for crossing outside a crosswalk. The Supreme Court reversed, holding that crossing outside a crosswalk was not prohibited, that the driver still owed a duty of due care, and that whether either party was negligent was a question for the jury. That principle still shapes how fault is evaluated whenever a pedestrian is struck midblock.
Making Midblock Crossings Safer
Most pedestrian deaths in the United States do not happen at intersections. According to a National Safety Council analysis of federal crash data, 75% of pedestrian traffic deaths in 2024 occurred on the open road rather than at intersections. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reports that 7,080 pedestrians were killed in traffic crashes in 2024, an average of one every 74 minutes. Long stretches between signals leave people with few convenient places to cross, especially along busy commercial roads. Road designers have several proven tools for these locations:
- Hybrid Beacons:Â Pedestrian hybrid beacons stop traffic on demand so people can cross midblock under a signal.
- Refuge Islands:Â Raised medians let pedestrians cross one direction of traffic at a time.
- Lighting:Â Better lighting at crossing points helps drivers see pedestrians earlier.
- Speed Management:Â Lower speeds give drivers more time to react and reduce the force of impact.
- Marked Crossings:Â High-visibility crosswalks placed where people naturally cross can close risky gaps between intersections.
Commercial corridors with shopping centers, bus stops, and homes on opposite sides of a wide road invite people to cross wherever they need to. When crossings are far apart, safety depends on roadway design as much as individual choices. Cities and counties have a responsibility to study where people actually walk and to build crossings that match. People struck while walking, and families who lose someone in these crashes, have the right to a full account of how a crash happened. They may also hold drivers and public entities accountable when unsafe driving or a dangerous road contributed.
Investigating Pedestrian Accidents in Banning
We at Feher Law extend our heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of Alberta Garcia. We hope this loss leads to a closer look at pedestrian safety along Highland Springs Avenue and to changes that prevent similar tragedies. Her death raises serious safety concerns about how people are expected to cross this busy corridor. Are there enough safe places to cross Highland Springs Avenue near Joshua Palmer Way?
Have you or a loved one been affected by a pedestrian accident in Banning or elsewhere in Riverside County? Laws exist specifically to protect people on foot, and drivers and public agencies can be held responsible when they fall short of their duties. Early official accounts of these crashes are often preliminary, and they may not capture everything that happened in the seconds before impact. Our team of safety advocates and accident investigators can help you understand what happened, from vehicle data and nearby camera footage to road design records and witness accounts. If you have questions about your rights or would like a free, independent investigation, we’re here for you anytime at (424) 433-4412.


