(310) 340-1112

AVAILABLE 24/7

Monica Ortega and Alan Ortega Meneses Injured in Redwood Village ICE Arrest in San Diego

Monica Ortega, 18, Raised Her Hands and Screamed for Her Father as ICE Agents Shoved Her Down and Aimed a Gun at Her, Then Took Alan Ortega Meneses Away From His Daughters

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA (November 17, 2026) – An 18-year-old college student identified as Monica Ortega and her father, Alan Ortega Meneses, were injured during an ICE arrest in the Redwood Village neighborhood of San Diego.

San Diego County officials are saying that the confrontation occurred on Friday morning. Alan Ortega Meneses, a single father who owns a business and supports his two daughters, was driving his truck near the family’s home when an unmarked SUV pulled in close behind him and struck the truck, according to Daylight San Diego.

A piece of the SUV became wedged in his truck, and agents broke the truck’s window. The family says officers used a Taser on Ortega Meneses, who now has a painful mark from the weapon, and a neighbor said agents never identified themselves.

Monica Ortega came into view with her hands raised as she approached her father’s truck, according to KPBS. Surveillance video obtained by ABC 10News shows an agent shoving her to the ground, and as she ran toward the cars in the street, she was struck by her father’s truck as it moved and was shoved down a second time.

The agent drew his gun and pointed it at the driver, then turned it toward Monica before switching to a Taser as she raised her hands in the air. Agents handcuffed her as she screamed, while her 11-year-old sister watched from nearby.

First responders took Monica Ortega to a hospital, and a neighbor said she suffered a badly sprained ankle, cuts on her hands and legs, and a back injury. She now walks on crutches, and her father is being held at the Otay Mesa Detention Center.

Monica said the agents drove off while she was still trying to speak, leaving her heartbroken.

The Department of Homeland Security claims Monica physically attacked officers and reached for a gun, and that her father drove into a government vehicle, but the family disputes that account. The 10News video does not show the alleged attack, and ICE says it is considering prosecution of both father and daughter.

Friends have started a GoFundMe to support Ortega Meneses and his daughters while the family searches for legal help. Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera met with the family and is calling for more police transparency around ICE activity.

The arrest follows a surge of enforcement activity in San Diego this fall, including arrests of parents and students near local schools in September. Local officials issued a statement condemning those arrests as an abuse of power. Questions may arise about why agents struck the family’s truck and whether any agent wore a body camera.

Liability for San Diego Immigration Arrest Injuries

Federal immigration agents are bound by the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits excessive force during any arrest, including against relatives and bystanders. Courts measure force by asking whether it was objectively reasonable, considering the threat a person posed, whether they were resisting, and how serious any suspected offense was. Pointing a firearm, firing a Taser, and using a vehicle to stop another car are all significant uses of force that require real justification. The Federal Tort Claims Act’s law enforcement proviso allows claims against the United States for assault, battery, and false arrest by federal officers. Several issues tend to decide these claims:

  • Threat Level: Force is hardest to justify against someone who is unarmed, outnumbered, or showing empty hands.
  • Weapon Display: Aiming a gun at a person who poses no immediate danger can itself amount to excessive force.
  • Taser Use: Electronic control devices are treated as intermediate force and require a meaningful threat or active resistance.
  • Vehicle Tactics: Ramming or boxing in a car can injure occupants and bystanders.
  • Identification: Whether officers identified themselves affects how a reasonable person would respond.

Federal courts in the West have long recognized that pointing a gun can violate the Constitution. In Robinson v. Solano County, decided by the full Ninth Circuit in 2002, a retired police officer was confronted by sheriff’s deputies responding to a report that a man had shot dogs near his property. As he walked toward them unarmed, a deputy pointed a gun at his head at close range while officers detained him. The court held that pointing a gun at an unarmed person who poses no danger can be excessive force, though the deputies received qualified immunity because that rule had not yet been clearly established.

Families Caught in Immigration Enforcement

Immigration arrests increasingly happen in front of children. At its peak in early February 2026, ICE held 68,289 people in detention, according to TRAC, a research center at Syracuse University. Relatives who rush to help can end up injured or detained. Families caught up in an arrest can protect their health and their rights in several ways:

  • Medical Care: Prompt treatment documents injuries.
  • Video Preservation: Home security systems may record over footage within days.
  • Witness Contacts: Neighbors can confirm what agents said and did.
  • Criminal Exposure: Anyone accused of interfering with officers should speak with counsel before making statements.
  • Children’s Wellbeing: Kids who witness a parent’s arrest may need counseling and steady support.

Immigration enforcement does not suspend the rules that govern how officers may use force. When agents act aggressively in residential streets, the risk extends to children, neighbors, and anyone nearby. People injured during an arrest have the right to seek accountability and compensation for medical care, lost income, and other harms.

Investigating Immigration Arrest Injuries in San Diego

We at Feher Law wish a full recovery and strength to Monica Ortega and Alan Ortega Meneses. We hope this family is reunited and that what happened on their street leads to real limits on how agents use force around parents, children, and neighbors. A daughter thrown to the ground while trying to reach her father raises serious safety concerns for every family in San Diego. What rules govern when federal agents may point a firearm at someone whose hands are raised?

Have you or a family member been hurt during an immigration arrest or police encounter in Redwood Village or elsewhere in San Diego? People injured by federal officers may be entitled to compensation for medical treatment, lost income, and the disruption to their daily lives. Federal agencies hold the body camera video, use-of-force reports, and arrest records, and their early accounts may not tell the whole story. Our team of safety advocates and accident investigators can help you understand what happened, from home security and bystander video to vehicle damage and neighbor accounts. If you have questions about your options or would like a free, independent investigation, we’re here for you anytime at (424) 433-4412.

About the Author

Tom Feher is a trial lawyer, founder and CEO of Feher Law, APC. His firm specializes in litigating and trying catastrophic injury, wrongful death and employment cases throughout California. At just 40 years old, he has tried over 50 jury trials to verdict. 

Recent News

window.lintrk('track', { conversion_id: 30256324 });