(310) 340-1112

AVAILABLE 24/7

Rudy Cuevas Injured in ICE Pepper Spraying Outside San Jose’s Main Jail

Rudy Cuevas Says ICE Agents Pepper-Sprayed Him After He Warned That a Man Pinned Beneath Them Could Not Breathe

SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA (November 19, 2026) – A Silicon Valley De-Bug organizer identified as Rudy Cuevas was injured when federal immigration agents pepper-sprayed him outside the Santa Clara County Main Jail in San Jose.

Santa Clara County officials are saying that the incident was reported around 11:30 a.m. on Friday, November 13. Cuevas was observing federal immigration activity outside the Main Jail when he saw several agents on top of a man, pinning him to the ground while he screamed, according to San José Spotlight.

Cuevas said he told the officers that the man could not breathe, and an agent then pepper-sprayed him. Two public defenders who were recording the arrest were also sprayed, including deputy public defender David Oyer, who described the pain to NBC Bay Area as the worst he had ever felt.

Cuevas told La Voz that he and two other legal observers were maced at the corner of Guadalupe Parkway and Hedding Street. He said the agents then began reversing their vehicle toward the group, “like they’re going to run us over.”

San Jose police responded to a call about a disturbance, and the agents drove away with the detained man. Cuevas said police were “discouraging” when he reported the incident, while Oyer later filed a formal complaint after being treated at a hospital.

On Wednesday, more than 40 advocates rallied outside the Main Jail to protest the presence of ICE agents around the county’s jails, Spotlight reported.

The incident follows weeks of rising tension around Santa Clara County’s jails. Observers documented ICE agents stopping cars leaving the jails, and one man was hospitalized on October 28 after agents used a Taser on him following his release from jail. The county’s Board of Supervisors voted in 2025 to establish ICE-free zones on county property, but a sheriff’s spokesperson said the department cannot interfere with another law enforcement agency. A retired San Jose police investigator told NBC Bay Area that people hurt by federal agents often face a “federal roadblock.” Will the agents’ actions be reviewed with the same scrutiny that applies to local officers?

Liability for San Jose Federal Agent Use-of-Force Incidents

Federal immigration agents are bound by the same constitutional limits on force as any other officer. Under the Fourth Amendment, as the U.S. Supreme Court explained in Graham v. Connor, force must be objectively reasonable given the threat, the seriousness of the situation, and whether a person is resisting. Because suing individual federal agents directly has become very difficult, most injury claims proceed against the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act. The act’s law enforcement proviso allows claims for assault and battery committed by federal law enforcement officers. Before filing suit, an injured person must first present an administrative claim to the agency within two years. Several factors tend to decide these cases:

  • Reasonableness: Courts weigh whether the person posed any threat and whether lesser measures would have worked.
  • Bystanders: Force directed at people who are not suspects in any crime receives especially close scrutiny.
  • Scope: A claim against the United States requires that the officer was acting within the scope of federal employment.
  • Procedure: The administrative claim must state the injury and the amount sought before a lawsuit can be filed.
  • Evidence: Phone videos, body camera footage, medical records, and witness statements often decide what really happened.

The Supreme Court has confirmed that this path to accountability is broad. In Millbrook v. United States (2013), a federal prisoner alleged that correctional officers assaulted him, and the lower courts dismissed his claim because the officers were not carrying out a search, seizure, or arrest at the time. A unanimous Supreme Court reversed, holding that the government waives its immunity for intentional torts by law enforcement officers acting within the scope of their employment, regardless of the specific activity they are performing. That ruling keeps the door open for people injured by federal officers in many settings.

The Hidden Health Effects of Pepper Spray

Pepper spray is often described as a harmless way to control a crowd, but research shows that it can cause serious harm. A systematic review published in BMC Public Health in 2017 examined 31 studies covering injuries from chemical irritants worldwide between 1990 and 2015. The researchers identified 5,131 injured people, two of whom died and 58 of whom suffered permanent disabilities. Of 9,261 recorded injuries, 8.7 percent were severe enough to need professional medical care, and most serious injuries affected the skin and eyes. People exposed to these chemicals should know the warning signs and the steps that protect their health:

  • Eyes: Prolonged burning, blurred vision, or sensitivity to light can signal corneal damage that needs an eye exam.
  • Breathing: Coughing, wheezing, or chest tightness can be dangerous for anyone with asthma or other lung conditions.
  • Skin: Burns and blistering can develop when the chemical stays on the skin, so prompt washing matters.
  • Follow-up: Symptoms that persist beyond the first day deserve a medical visit and written documentation.
  • Records: Photos, medical notes, and the names of witnesses help show the full extent of the injury.

Chemical sprays should never be used casually, especially in crowded public places. Agencies that rely on these weapons have a responsibility to train officers, document each use, and answer for injuries that result. Injured people may be entitled to compensation for medical care, lost wages, and the pain and disruption these injuries cause. Strict federal deadlines and procedures apply, so understanding those rights early can make a difference.

Investigating Federal Agent Use of Force in San Jose

We at Feher Law wish a full recovery to Rudy Cuevas. We hope this incident brings real accountability and clearer limits on how federal agents use force around the county’s jails. Pepper spray used on community members watching an arrest raises serious safety concerns for everyone who visits these facilities. What led federal agents to use pepper spray on observers who were documenting an arrest from a public street corner?

Have you or a loved one been hurt by federal agents or police in San Jose or elsewhere in Santa Clara County? The law limits how much force officers may use, and people injured by excessive force may be entitled to compensation. When federal agencies are involved, they control the body camera footage, incident reports, and use-of-force records, and early official accounts are often one-sided. Our team of safety advocates and accident investigators can help you understand what happened, from bystander video and agency records to medical documentation and witness accounts. If you have questions about your rights or would like a free, independent investigation, we are here for you anytime at (424) 433-4412.

Important Notice

The articles on this site are general information published by Feher Law, APC for marketing and educational purposes only. They are not legal advice and do not create an attorney-client relationship.

Nothing on this page is a statement about the value of any case or the legal opinion of any Feher Law attorney about any specific matter. There is no standard settlement amount for any injury or case. What a claim is worth depends on the claim. No result is predicted, promised or guaranteed, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Laws change and every situation is different. Speak with a licensed California attorney before acting on anything you read here. For a free consultation about your own situation, call (424) 622-3350.

Recent News

window.lintrk('track', { conversion_id: 30256324 });