David Braff Charged in McKevett Elementary Sexual Abuse Case in Santa Paula
State Panel Declined to Discipline Former Counselor David Lane Braff Jr. Years Before His Arrest on Child Sexual Abuse Charges
SANTA PAULA, CALIFORNIA (November 19, 2026) – A former elementary school counselor identified as David Braff has been charged with sexually abusing students at McKevett Elementary School in Santa Paula.
Ventura County officials are saying that the alleged abuse occurred between 2015 and 2019, while Braff worked as a counselor at McKevett Elementary School. Braff was arrested on November 22, 2024, and charged with felony counts of lewd acts upon a child under 14, according to the Santa Paula Times.
Prosecutors later amended the complaint to add more alleged victims, including one connected to Braff’s work with the Conejo Recreation and Park District in 2004 and 2005. He now faces trial on allegations involving 15 students, 13 of them from Santa Paula, has pleaded not guilty, and has been jailed since November 2024, according to KQED.
A ProPublica and KQED investigation found that Santa Paula Unified reported Braff to the state Commission on Teacher Credentialing in 2019, after at least seven students raised concerns, and that he resigned during the district’s investigation. Braff told the district he never touched students inappropriately.
The commission did not interview the students, and a volunteer panel that reviewed 198 cases over three days in December 2020 did not recommend discipline. Braff went on to work as a counselor at a Los Angeles-area charter elementary school, and the state suspended his credentials only after his 2024 arrest.
The commission’s problems are not new. A 2011 state audit found the agency had let misconduct reports pile up, including a backlog of about 12,600 cases in 2009.
Braff held numerous positions working with children over two decades, according to the Santa Paula Times. Families may want to know what each of those employers checked before hiring him and whether any earlier concerns were ever passed along.
Liability for Santa Paula School Sexual Abuse
California law imposes special duties on schools because parents must entrust their children to them. Under Government Code section 815.2, a public school district is liable for injuries caused by its employees acting within the scope of their employment, which can include negligent supervision by administrators. Penal Code section 11166 requires teachers, counselors, and administrators to report suspected child abuse to police or child welfare authorities. For abuse that occurred before 2024, Code of Civil Procedure section 340.11 generally gives survivors until 22 years after reaching adulthood, or five years after discovering certain harm, to file suit, and those claims need not first be presented to a government entity. Responsibility often depends on the following:
- Hiring Practices:Â Schools must screen applicants, including checking references and credential history, before placing adults with children.
- Supervision Duties:Â Administrators who know or should know an employee poses a risk must act to protect students.
- Mandated Reporting:Â School staff who suspect abuse must report it promptly to law enforcement or child protective services, not only to supervisors.
- Credential Oversight:Â State licensing is meant to keep unfit educators away from students after misconduct reports.
- Institutional Records:Â Personnel files, complaint logs, investigation notes, and credential filings often show what an institution knew and when.
The California Supreme Court has made clear that districts can answer for supervisors’ failures. In C.A. v. William S. Hart Union High School District (2012), a student sued his public high school district over sexual harassment and abuse by the school’s head guidance counselor. The court held that a district may be vicariously liable when its administrators and supervisors negligently hire, retain, or supervise an employee they know or should know poses a risk to students. The ruling recognized that responsibility for student safety does not rest on teachers and counselors alone. It also rests on the administrators who decide who works with children and how closely that work is monitored.
Recognizing and Reporting Educator Misconduct
Sexual misconduct by school employees is more common than many parents realize. A report prepared for the U.S. Department of Education in 2004 estimated that 9.6% of students in grades 8 through 11 had experienced educator sexual misconduct during their school careers. A decade later, the U.S. Government Accountability Office found in 2014 that no federal agency systematically tracks the extent of sexual abuse by school personnel. That data gap makes awareness among parents and staff even more important. Families and educators can take several steps to protect children and respond when concerns arise:
- Boundary Policies:Â Clear rules on one-on-one time, closed doors, and private communication help schools spot troubling patterns early.
- Careful Listening:Â Children often disclose in pieces, and calm, supportive responses make it more likely they will keep talking.
- Direct Reporting:Â Concerns should go to police or child protective services, not only to school administrators.
- Written Notes:Â Dates, statements, and the names of school officials contacted can be critical later.
- Ongoing Support:Â Trauma-informed counseling helps children process what happened and supports long-term recovery.
Protecting students requires every adult in a school system to treat warning signs seriously and act on them. Licensing agencies, districts, and charter schools all share responsibility for making sure a report in one place follows an educator to the next. Survivors of childhood sexual abuse in California have strong legal rights, including extended time to file claims against both abusers and the institutions that failed to stop them. Survivors may be entitled to compensation for therapy, medical care, and the lasting harm abuse causes. Pursuing accountability also pressures institutions to close the gaps that allow abuse to continue.
Investigating School Sexual Abuse in Santa Paula
We at Feher Law send our support and best wishes for healing to the students and families who came forward about former McKevett Elementary counselor David Braff. We hope the criminal process brings the full truth to light and that California’s credentialing system is reformed so that every misconduct report is thoroughly investigated. This case raises serious safety concerns about how schools and the state respond to allegations against educators. Why was a counselor reported to the state in 2019 still able to work with young children for years afterward?
Have you or a loved one been affected by sexual abuse at a school in Santa Paula or elsewhere in Ventura County? Survivors of childhood sexual abuse may be entitled to compensation for counseling, medical care, and the lasting disruption abuse causes. Institutions often close ranks when something goes wrong, and the districts and state agencies that hold key records may be slow to share them. Our team of safety advocates and investigators can help you understand what happened, from personnel files and complaint records to credentialing filings that show who knew what and when. If you have questions about your rights or need support of any kind, we’re here for you anytime at (424) 433-4412.


